stagingmate
Data study · Agents

Agents Respond to Google Reviews, but Only 28% of Bad Ones

Real estate agents reply to 48.1% of their Google reviews, but only 28.2% of one- and two-star reviews get an answer, against 49.8% of 5-star reviews. Agents who respond to Google reviews write much longer answers to bad ones: a median 346 characters for a 1-star review against 122 for a 5-star review. A quarter of agent listings, 25.4%, reply to none of their recent reviews.

Analysis of 25,351 Google reviews and owner replies for 998 US real estate agent and brokerage listings · the newest 40 reviews of listings with 10 or more reviews, about 20 per state, collected November 2026

Stagingmate Research
Published Nov 11, 2026 · 9 min read
A phone, coffee mug and house keys on a wooden desk
Data source
Google Maps business listings in the real estate agency and real estate agent categories, and the newest Google reviews of each listing with any owner reply and its date
Collected
November 2026
Sample
998 agent and brokerage listings with at least 10 Google reviews, about 20 per state in all 50 states, and their newest 25,351 reviews (up to 40 per listing); reply speed from the 1,049 reviews posted in the 8 weeks before collection

Key findings

  1. 1Real estate agents reply to 48.1% of their Google reviews, based on the newest 25,351 reviews of 998 agent and brokerage listings.
  2. 2Only 28.2% of one- and two-star agent reviews get an owner reply, against 49.8% of 5-star reviews.
  3. 3Agents who respond to Google reviews write a median 346 characters in reply to a 1-star review, almost three times the 122 characters they write for a 5-star review.
  4. 425.4% of agent listings reply to none of their recent reviews, while 11.7% reply to every one.
  5. 5For reviews posted in the last 8 weeks, the median reply came 7 days after the review, and 15.4% of replies came within 2 days.
  6. 6Agents in the Midwest reply to 55.6% of their reviews, the highest of the four US regions, against 45.3% in the South.

Summary

A seller is comparing two agents on Google Maps. Both sit close to 5 stars. Near the top of the first profile is a 1-star review from last spring, and under it the agent has written a calm, short answer. On the second profile a similar review sits with nothing under it. The seller reads both, and only one of them gives her the agent's side of the story.

Owner replies are the one part of a Google review profile that the agent writes. Google prints the reply directly under the review, so a future client reads the two together. Advice on how to respond to Google reviews is easy to find, but there is little data on what agents actually do: how often they reply, which ratings they answer, how long they take and how much they write. This study measures that across 998 agent and brokerage listings in all 50 states.

Agents reply to about half of their reviews, 48.1%, and their replies lean toward praise. A 5-star review gets an answer 49.8% of the time, a one- or two-star review 28.2% of the time. When agents do answer a bad review they write far more, a median 346 characters against 122 for a 5-star thank-you. A quarter of listings, 25.4%, answer none of their recent reviews at all.

What we measured

In November 2026 we took Google Maps business listings returned for the real estate agency and real estate agent categories in all 50 states and kept those with at least 10 Google reviews, so every listing had enough reviews to read. From each state we drew about 20 listings in a fixed shuffled order, which spreads the sample across each state's list rather than taking its most prominent names: 998 listings in all. For each one we collected its newest 40 Google reviews, or every review if it had fewer, with any owner reply and the dates Google shows. That gave 25,351 reviews: 23,503 at 5 stars, 369 at 4 stars, 197 at 3 stars, 138 at 2 stars and 1,144 at 1 star.

A reply is any owner response visible under the review on collection day. A negative review is one with 1 or 2 stars, 1,282 reviews in all. The overall reply rate counts every review once, so it gives more weight to listings with more reviews in the sample; the per-listing figures, such as the share of listings that never reply and the median listing reply rate, count each listing once. Reply length is the number of characters in the reply. Review length counts only reviews with written text, since 12.6% of reviews are a star rating with no words.

Reply speed needs an exact reply date, and Google shows the dates of older replies only roughly, as a number of weeks, months or years ago. For that reason, reply speed uses only the 1,049 reviews posted in the 8 weeks before collection, the window where reply dates are precise. 52.6% of those reviews had a reply by collection day, and 533 of the replies had a usable date on or after the review date. Some recent reviews will still get a reply after collection, so the share answered will rise and the median reply time may lengthen.

Limits: 40 reviews per listing covers each listing's recent history, not its full record. The sample covers listings with 10 or more reviews, which are likely more active on Google than a typical agent profile. The study records whether a reply exists, how long it is and when it was posted; it does not read what the reply says or its tone. This edition does not measure reply speed for reviews older than 8 weeks. Regions follow the four US Census regions, each with at least 180 listings, and state figures are not reported because each state has only about 20 listings.

Agents reply to about half of their Google reviews

48.1%

of the newest Google reviews of agent and brokerage listings have an owner reply

Of the 25,351 reviews, 48.1% carry an owner reply. The typical listing replies to fewer: the median listing has answered 39% of its recent reviews. The two figures differ because the overall rate counts every review while the listing figure counts each listing once, and replying is concentrated among listings that answer almost everything.

Agent listings by share of their recent Google reviews with an owner reply
None
25.4%
Under 25%
16.5%
25% to 74%
26.5%
75% to 99%
19.9%
Every review
11.7%
Source: Stagingmate analysis of 25,351 Google reviews of 998 US agent and brokerage listings · Google Maps, November 2026

Replying is a habit: a quarter of listings never reply, and almost a third answer three reviews in four or more.

A quarter of listings, 25.4%, have not replied to any of their recent reviews, and another 16.5% reply to fewer than one in four. At the other end, 31.6% reply to at least three in four, including 11.7% that answer every review in the sample. The middle group, 26.5%, replies to some reviews and not others, which is where the choice of which reviews to answer shows up.

Bad reviews get a reply far less often than 5-star ones

28.2%

of one- and two-star agent reviews have an owner reply, against 49.8% of 5-star reviews

Of the 1,282 one- and two-star reviews, 28.2% have a reply. Five-star reviews are answered 49.8% of the time, about 1.8 times as often. Two-star reviews get slightly more replies than 1-star reviews, 34.1% against 27.4%, and the middle ratings get the fewest: 20.3% of 3-star reviews and 22.5% of 4-star reviews have a reply.

Share of agent Google reviews with an owner reply, by star rating
1 star
27.4%
2 stars
34.1%
3 stars
20.3%
4 stars
22.5%
5 stars
49.8%
Source: Stagingmate analysis of 25,351 Google reviews of 998 US agent and brokerage listings · Google Maps, November 2026

Agents answer half of their 5-star reviews and about a quarter of everything below 5 stars.

Five-star reviews make up 92.7% of the reviews collected, so they set the overall reply rate. The pattern below them still matters. The reviews a careful client is most likely to open, the low ones near the top of a profile, are the ones least likely to carry the agent's answer. Reviews with stars but no written text get a reply 28.5% of the time, about the same rate as negative reviews.

Replies to 1-star reviews run almost three times as long

346

median characters in an agent's reply to a 1-star Google review

The median agent reply is 125 characters, about one or two short sentences, while the median written review is 281 characters. Length rises steadily as the rating falls. Replies to 5-star reviews run a median 122 characters and replies to 4-star reviews 126, then 166 for 3-star reviews, 315 for 2-star reviews and 346 for 1-star reviews.

Owner replies to agent Google reviews, by star rating
RatingReviewsShare with a replyMedian reply length (characters)
1 star1,14427.4%346
2 stars13834.1%315
3 stars19720.3%166
4 stars36922.5%126
5 stars23,50349.8%122

Source: Stagingmate analysis of 25,351 Google reviews of 998 US agent and brokerage listings · Google Maps, November 2026

The numbers point to two kinds of reply. Praise gets a brief thank-you, shorter than the review it answers. Criticism gets an explanation, and agents who respond to Google reviews at 1 star write more than the typical reviewer does. A long answer is not always a better one, but the length shows how much more effort a negative review draws from the agents who choose to answer it.

Recent reviews get a reply in a median 7 days

7 days

median time from review to owner reply, for reviews posted in the last 8 weeks

Among the 1,049 reviews posted in the 8 weeks before collection, 52.6% already had a reply. For the 533 replies with a usable date, the median time from review to reply was 7 days. 15.4% of replies came within 2 days of the review and 48% within a week, so about half took longer than a week.

Time from review to owner reply, agent Google reviews from the last 8 weeks
Within 2 days
15.4%
3 to 7 days
32.6%
More than 7 days
52%
Source: Stagingmate analysis of 533 dated owner replies to 1,049 agent Google reviews posted in the 8 weeks before collection · Google Maps, November 2026

Only about one reply in seven arrives within 2 days of the review.

A reply that arrives a week later still sits under the review for good, so slow replies are not wasted. The cost of waiting falls on the days in between: a new 1-star review is most visible in the first days after it appears, at the top of a profile sorted by newest, and that is when most of them have no answer yet.

Midwest agents reply most often, at 55.6%

55.6%

of recent Google reviews of Midwest agent listings have an owner reply

Agent listings in the Midwest reply to 55.6% of their recent reviews, about 10 points more than the other three regions. Those three sit within a point of each other: 46.1% in the Northeast, 45.9% in the West and 45.3% in the South. Each region holds at least 180 listings in the sample, from 180 in the Northeast to 319 in the South.

Share of agent Google reviews with an owner reply, by region
Midwest
55.6%
Northeast
46.1%
West
45.9%
South
45.3%
Source: Stagingmate analysis of 25,351 Google reviews of 998 US agent and brokerage listings · Google Maps, November 2026

Replying is a little more common in the Midwest; elsewhere the rate is close to 46%.

Listings that reply more have more reviews, not higher ratings

Ratings barely change with reply habits. Listings that never reply have a median rating of 4.9 stars, and listings that reply to every review a median 5.0. The bigger difference is volume: listings that reply to 75% to 99% of their reviews have a median 32 Google reviews in total, and those that never reply a median 17.

Agent listings by reply habit
Share of recent reviews answeredShare of listingsMedian ratingMedian total reviews
None25.4%4.917
Under 25%16.5%4.926
25% to 74%26.5%5.023
75% to 99%19.9%5.032
Every review11.7%5.027

Source: Stagingmate analysis of 25,351 Google reviews of 998 US agent and brokerage listings · Google Maps, November 2026

This does not show that replying brings in more reviews. Agents who are active on their Google profile are likely to ask clients for reviews and to answer them, so the two habits travel together. What the table does show is that replying is not something only struggling or top-rated listings do: it runs across the whole range of agents, and the median rating is 4.9 or 5.0 in every group.

What this means for agents

Answer the low ratings first. Only 28.2% of one- and two-star reviews have a reply, so a short, calm answer already sets an agent apart from most listings. If you have limited time and are working out how to respond to Google reviews, a 1-star review deserves the reply more than a 5-star one, because it is the review a cautious client is most likely to open.

Reply within a week, and sooner for negative reviews. The median recent reply came 7 days after the review, and only 15.4% came within 2 days. Keep thank-you replies short, as most agents already do at a median 122 characters, and save the longer answers for the reviews that need an explanation.

Reviews and listing photos are the two things a client checks before calling, and both are on the agent's own schedule. If you have been searching for virtual staging near me, you do not need a local firm: the photos are staged online, so an empty room can be shown furnished in any market.

For listings where you would rather hand the photo work off, compare what virtual staging services include and how fast they turn photos around, and spend the time saved answering the reviews that are still waiting.

Cite and download

Cite this study

Stagingmate Research. (2026). Agents Respond to Google Reviews, but Only 28% of Bad Ones. Stagingmate. https://stagingmate.com/research/how-agents-reply-to-google-reviews

Use this data

Free to use and republish, as long as you credit Stagingmate Research with a link to this page. Need a local cut or a quote? Email support@stagingmate.com.

↓ Download the data (CSV)

Frequently asked questions

48.1%, based on the newest 25,351 Google reviews of 998 US agent and brokerage listings. The median listing replies to 39% of its recent reviews, and 25.4% of listings reply to none.

Related studies