stagingmate
Data study · Agents

Real Estate Local SEO: Top 3 Map Agents Have 38 Reviews

For real estate local SEO, the three agents at the top of Google Maps for realtor hold a median 38 reviews, across 198 US cities. That is only a few more than the 34 held by the agents in positions 4 to 20, and a quarter of top-3 listings have 17 or fewer. Nearly all of them share the basics: a 5.0 rating, a website and posted hours.

Analysis of 3,960 Google Maps listings, the top 20 for realtor in each of 198 US cities, searched from inside each city · 594 top-3 listings compared with 3,366 in positions 4 to 20, collected November 2026

Stagingmate Research
Published Nov 11, 2026 · 7 min read
A smartphone in a parked car on a quiet residential street
Data source
Google Maps search results for realtor, with each search run from inside the city, recording each listing's position, reviews, rating, photos, website, opening hours and category
Collected
November 2026
Sample
198 large US cities, at least one in every state, with the top 20 listings in each: 3,960 listings, of which 594 sit in the top 3

Key findings

  1. 1The top 3 Google Maps listings for realtor hold a median 38 reviews, against 34 for listings in positions 4 to 20.
  2. 2A quarter of top-3 listings have 17 or fewer reviews, 13% have fewer than 10 and 2% have none.
  3. 3The median rating is 5.0 stars both in the top 3 and in positions 4 to 20, so rating does not separate them.
  4. 491.8% of top-3 listings link to a website and 96% post opening hours, close to the 91.1% and 95.3% further down the list.
  5. 564.8% of top-3 listings are categorized as a real estate agency and 29.5% as a real estate agent.
  6. 6Top-3 listings in cities ranked 51 to 100 hold the most reviews, a median 52, against 35 in the largest 50 cities.

Summary

A buyer who has just moved to a new city opens Google Maps and types realtor. Three agents appear above the fold with their stars, review counts and a button to call. Below them sit 17 more, most with the same five stars. The buyer calls one of the first three and never scrolls.

Those three spots are the most valuable free placement in real estate local SEO, and agents often ask how many reviews it takes to earn one. Review counts are easy to see and easy to change, so they get most of the attention. But Google ranks map results on how relevant, how close and how prominent each business is, and reviews are only one part of prominence. This study measures what the top 3 actually hold in 198 cities and how they compare with the listings just below them.

The typical top-3 agent listing has 38 reviews, a 5.0 rating, a website, posted hours and 15 photos. The listings in positions 4 to 20 look almost the same, with a median 34 reviews and the same 5.0 rating. A quarter of top-3 listings have 17 or fewer reviews. Reviews help, but they do not by themselves decide who makes the top 3.

What we measured

In November 2026 we searched Google Maps for realtor in about 200 large US cities, with each search run from inside that city, the kind of result a realtor near me search shows someone standing there. The cities cover at least one in every state. 198 searches returned results, and we kept the top 20 listings from each: 3,960 listings, of which 594 sit in positions 1 to 3. Every city returned at least three listings.

For each listing we recorded its position, its number of Google reviews, its star rating, its number of photos, whether it links to a website, whether it posts opening hours and its main business category. We compare the top 3 with positions 4 to 20. The median is the middle value, so half of listings hold more and half fewer. The 25th percentile is the value a quarter of listings fall at or below. City size bands follow the order of the city list, which is sorted by population: the largest 50 cities, cities 51 to 100 and cities 101 to 200.

Limits: the searches are one per city on one day, run from a single point in the city, and map rankings shift with the searcher's exact location. This edition does not measure distance from the searcher to each listing, so it cannot separate the effect of proximity from that of reviews. The figures describe what top listings hold, not what caused them to rank, and a listing in the top 3 of one city may sit lower in the next town over.

Top-3 map listings for realtor hold a median 38 reviews

38

median Google reviews held by the top 3 map listings for realtor, across 198 cities

Across 594 top-3 listings, the median is 38 Google reviews. Listings in positions 4 to 20 hold a median 34. The difference is four reviews, small next to the range of review counts in either group. On reviews alone, a listing in seventh place often looks much like one in second.

Google Maps listings for realtor: top 3 compared with positions 4 to 20
MeasureTop 3Positions 4 to 20
Listings5943,366
Median reviews3834
25th percentile of reviews1713
Fewer than 10 reviews13%18.7%
Median rating5.05.0
Median photos1514
Links to a website91.8%91.1%
Posts opening hours96%95.3%

Source: Stagingmate analysis of 3,960 Google Maps listings for realtor in 198 US cities · Google Maps results, November 2026

The low end is where the two groups differ most. A quarter of top-3 listings have 17 or fewer reviews, against 13 or fewer in positions 4 to 20, and 13% of top-3 listings have fewer than 10 reviews, against 18.7% further down. A thin review count is less common in the top 3, but it is not rare.

A quarter of top-3 agents have 17 or fewer reviews

13%

of top-3 map listings for realtor have fewer than 10 Google reviews

Plenty of agents reach the top 3 without a large review count. 25% of top-3 listings have 17 or fewer reviews, 13% have fewer than 10 and 2% have none at all. Those listings are most likely ranking on proximity and relevance: they are close to where the search was run and their name, category and profile match the search well.

Share of Google Maps listings for realtor with fewer than 10 reviews
Top 3
13%
Positions 4 to 20
18.7%
Source: Stagingmate analysis of 3,960 Google Maps listings for realtor in 198 US cities · Google Maps results, November 2026

Low review counts are less common in the top 3 but still appear in about one listing in eight.

For an agent with a new or thin profile, that is the useful finding. A median of 38 is a reasonable target, but it is not a gate. Real estate local SEO on Maps rewards a well-matched, complete profile in the right place, and reviews add to that rather than replace it.

Ratings, websites and hours barely separate the top 3

5.0

median star rating in the top 3 and in positions 4 to 20 alike

The median rating is 5.0 in both groups, so star ratings do not distinguish them. The same holds for the profile basics: 91.8% of top-3 listings link to a website and 96% post opening hours, against 91.1% and 95.3% in positions 4 to 20. Top-3 listings show a median 15 photos and the rest 14.

Profile basics on Google Maps listings for realtor, top 3 and positions 4 to 20
Website, top 3
91.8%
Website, positions 4-20
91.1%
Opening hours, top 3
96%
Opening hours, positions 4-20
95.3%
Source: Stagingmate analysis of 3,960 Google Maps listings for realtor in 198 US cities · Google Maps results, November 2026

Nearly every listing in the top 20 has a website and posted hours.

These basics behave like an entry ticket. Almost every listing that appears in the top 20 for realtor has them, so having them does not move a listing up within the 20. Lacking them is a different matter: a profile without a website or hours is unusual anywhere on the list.

Agencies take 64.8% of top-3 spots

64.8%

of top-3 map listings for realtor are categorized as a real estate agency

Most top-3 listings use one of two categories. 64.8% are listed as a real estate agency and 29.5% as a real estate agent. Commercial real estate agencies make up 2.7%, real estate consultants 1.5% and associations 0.5%.

Main business category of top-3 Google Maps listings for realtor
Real estate agency
64.8%
Real estate agent
29.5%
Commercial real estate agency
2.7%
Real estate consultant
1.5%
Association or organization
0.5%
Apartment rental agency
0.3%
Property management company
0.3%
Source: Stagingmate analysis of 594 top-3 Google Maps listings for realtor in 198 US cities · Google Maps results, November 2026

Agency listings outnumber individual agent listings in the top 3 by more than two to one.

Agency listings usually belong to brokerage offices, which can gather reviews from the clients of many agents. Individual agents still hold close to three top-3 spots in ten. Choosing real estate agent or real estate agency as the main category keeps a profile in the two groups that fill nearly all of the top 3.

Mid-sized cities have the most reviewed top-3 agents

52

median reviews for top-3 realtor listings in cities ranked 51 to 100

The review bar is not highest in the biggest cities. Top-3 listings in cities ranked 51 to 100 hold a median 52 reviews, against 35 in the 50 largest cities and 36 in cities ranked 101 to 200. Cities 51 to 100 also have the fewest top-3 listings under 10 reviews, 10.2%.

Top-3 Google Maps listings for realtor, by city size
City sizeTop-3 listingsMedian reviews25th percentileUnder 10 reviewsMedian photos
Largest 50 cities150351514.7%14
Cities 51-100147521910.2%18
Cities 101-200297361713.5%14

Source: Stagingmate analysis of 594 top-3 Google Maps listings for realtor in 198 US cities · Google Maps results, November 2026

In the largest cities, a search run from one point covers a small slice of a big market, so the top 3 are likely to be nearby offices rather than the most reviewed agents in the metro. Mid-sized cities have fewer agents spread over a smaller area, which may let the most established listings show for more of the city.

What this means for agents

Aim for about 40 reviews, but do not wait for them. The top 3 for realtor hold a median 38, and a quarter of them have 17 or fewer, so real estate local SEO on Maps is won by profiles that match the search and sit close to the searcher as much as by review counts. Ask every closed client for a review and keep the count growing steadily.

Get the basics right first. Over 90% of listings in the top 20 have a website and posted hours, and the top 3 show a median 15 photos. Pick real estate agent or real estate agency as the main category, since those two cover nearly all top-3 listings.

Keep the profile photos current with listing work. In a city such as Seattle, where listings run from condos to older houses, staged rooms make a profile look active. See virtual staging seattle examples for condos and craftsman homes.

In older markets the same applies to period homes with small rooms. See boston virtual staging examples for older housing stock.

Cite and download

Cite this study

Stagingmate Research. (2026). Real Estate Local SEO: Top 3 Map Agents Have 38 Reviews. Stagingmate. https://stagingmate.com/research/local-map-pack-for-realtor-near-me-review-counts-needed-to-rank

Use this data

Free to use and republish, as long as you credit Stagingmate Research with a link to this page. Need a local cut or a quote? Email support@stagingmate.com.

↓ Download the data (CSV)

Frequently asked questions

There is no fixed number. The top 3 map listings for realtor hold a median 38 reviews across 198 cities, but a quarter have 17 or fewer and 13% have fewer than 10.

Related studies