- Data source
- Google Maps business listings for property management companies, and the newest Google reviews of each listing with any owner reply and its date
- Collected
- November 2026
- Sample
- 838 US property management listings with at least 10 Google reviews, up to 20 per state, and their newest 25,545 reviews (up to 40 per listing); reply speed from the 2,225 reviews posted in the 8 weeks before collection
Key findings
- 1Property managers reply to 44.5% of their Google reviews, based on the newest 25,545 reviews of 838 listings.
- 2Only 35.5% of 1-star property manager reviews get an owner reply, against 49% of 5-star reviews.
- 3Managers who respond to tenant reviews at 1 star write a median 384 characters, against 147 for a 5-star review.
- 429.4% of property management listings reply to none of their recent reviews, and 8.1% reply to every one.
- 5For reviews posted in the last 8 weeks, the median reply came 7 days after the review, and 21% of replies came within 2 days.
- 6Listings that reply to every review have a median 4.6-star rating, against 3.5 for listings that never reply.
- 7Listings with 100 or more Google reviews reply to a median 71.3% of them, against 4.5% for listings with 10 to 24.
Summary
A renter is choosing between two buildings run by different managers. Both profiles carry a run of 1-star reviews about repairs and deposits. On the first, many of those reviews have a reply from the manager explaining what happened. On the second, the complaints stand alone. The renter cannot tell which manager is better, but only one of them has told its side.
Ratings for property managers swing between 5 stars and 1 star, and 5,796 of the 25,545 reviews in this sample are 1 star. Advice on how to respond to tenant reviews is easy to find; data on what managers actually do is not. This study measures owner replies across 838 property management listings in all 50 states: how often managers reply, which ratings they answer, how long they take and how much they write.
Managers reply to 44.5% of reviews, and their replies lean toward praise: 49% of 5-star reviews get an answer, against 35.5% of 1-star reviews. When they do answer a 1-star review they write far more, a median 384 characters. Replying goes with better ratings: listings that answer every review have a median 4.6 stars, listings that never reply 3.5.
What we measured
In November 2026 we took Google Maps business listings for property management companies in all 50 states and kept those with at least 10 Google reviews. From each state we drew up to 20 listings in a fixed shuffled order, which spreads the sample across each state's list rather than taking its most prominent names, and collected the newest 40 Google reviews of each, or every review if it had fewer, with any owner reply and the dates Google shows. 838 listings returned reviews, giving 25,545 reviews: 17,425 at 5 stars, 1,114 at 4 stars, 641 at 3 stars, 569 at 2 stars and 5,796 at 1 star.
A reply is any owner response visible under the review on collection day. A negative review is one with 1 or 2 stars, 6,365 reviews in all. Reviews come from tenants, owners, applicants and others, and the reply figures cover all of them. The overall reply rate counts every review once, so it gives more weight to listings with more reviews in the sample; the per-listing figures, such as the share of listings that never reply and the median listing reply rate, count each listing once. Reply length is the number of characters in the reply. Listing size is the total number of Google reviews a listing shows.
Reply speed needs an exact reply date, and Google shows the dates of older replies only roughly, as a number of weeks, months or years ago. For that reason, reply speed uses only the 2,225 reviews posted in the 8 weeks before collection, the window where reply dates are precise. 1,145 of those reviews had a reply with a usable date on or after the review date. Some recent reviews will still get a reply after collection, so the median reply time may lengthen.
Limits: 40 reviews per listing covers each listing's recent history, not its full record, and the sample covers listings with 10 or more reviews, which are likely more active on Google than a typical manager. The study records whether a reply exists, how long it is and when it was posted; it does not read what the reply says or its tone. This edition does not measure reply speed for reviews older than 8 weeks. Ratings and reply habits move together, but the data cannot show which causes which. Regions follow the four US Census regions, each with at least 126 listings; state figures are not reported because each state has at most 20 listings.
Property managers reply to 44.5% of their Google reviews
of the newest Google reviews of property management listings have an owner reply
Of the 25,545 reviews, 44.5% carry an owner reply. The typical listing replies to far fewer: the median listing has answered 27.5% of its recent reviews. The gap comes from the way replies are spread. Listings with many reviews tend to answer most of them, and they contribute more reviews to the overall rate.
Close to half of listings answer fewer than one review in four.
Close to a third of listings, 29.4%, have not replied to any of their recent reviews, and another 17.8% reply to fewer than one in four. At the other end, 28.3% reply to at least three in four, including 8.1% that answer every review in the sample. The middle group, 24.6%, answers some reviews and not others.
1-star reviews get a reply less often than 5-star ones
of 1-star property manager reviews have an owner reply, against 49% of 5-star reviews
Of the 5,796 one-star reviews, 35.5% have a reply. Five-star reviews are answered 49% of the time. Two-star reviews sit close to 1-star at 36.7%, and the middle ratings get the fewest replies: 26.4% of 3-star reviews and 34.6% of 4-star reviews.
Managers answer about half of their 5-star reviews and about a third of everything below.
Taken together, 35.6% of the 6,365 one- and two-star reviews have a reply. Those are the reviews a cautious renter or owner is most likely to read, and close to two in three of them carry no answer from the manager. For managers working out how to respond to tenant reviews, the first gap to close is the share of complaints that get any reply at all.
Replies to 1-star reviews run more than twice as long
median characters in a manager's reply to a 1-star Google review
The median manager reply is 183 characters. Replies to 5-star reviews run a median 147 characters and replies to 4-star reviews 144. Length then rises: 251 characters for 3-star reviews, 383 for 2-star reviews and 384 for 1-star reviews.
| Rating | Reviews | Share with a reply | Median reply length (characters) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 star | 5,796 | 35.5% | 384 |
| 2 stars | 569 | 36.7% | 383 |
| 3 stars | 641 | 26.4% | 251 |
| 4 stars | 1,114 | 34.6% | 144 |
| 5 stars | 17,425 | 49% | 147 |
Source: Stagingmate analysis of 25,545 Google reviews of 838 US property management listings · Google Maps, November 2026
Even replies to praise run a couple of sentences at 147 characters, and replies to complaints are longer again. Managers who respond to tenant reviews at 1 or 2 stars write about two and a half times as much as for a 5-star review, which points to an explanation rather than a courtesy, though this study does not read what replies say.
Recent reviews get a reply in a median 7 days
median time from review to owner reply, for reviews posted in the last 8 weeks
Among the 2,225 reviews posted in the 8 weeks before collection, 1,145 had a reply with a usable date. The median time from review to reply was 7 days. 21% of replies came within 2 days and 53.2% within a week, so close to half took longer than a week.
About one reply in five arrives within 2 days of the review.
A complaint is most visible in the days after it appears, at the top of a profile sorted by newest. With only about one reply in five arriving within 2 days, most new reviews, the low ones included, spend their most visible days without an answer.
Listings that reply more have higher ratings
median rating of listings that reply to every review, against 3.5 for those that never reply
Ratings rise with reply habits. Listings that never reply have a median rating of 3.5 stars. Those that reply to fewer than a quarter of their reviews have a median 4.1, those that reply to a quarter to three quarters 4.0, those that reply to 75% to 99% 4.3, and those that reply to every review 4.6.
| Share of recent reviews answered | Share of listings | Listings | Median rating |
|---|---|---|---|
| None | 29.4% | 246 | 3.5 |
| Under 25% | 17.8% | 149 | 4.1 |
| 25% to 74% | 24.6% | 206 | 4.0 |
| 75% to 99% | 20.2% | 169 | 4.3 |
| Every review | 8.1% | 68 | 4.6 |
Source: Stagingmate analysis of 25,545 Google reviews of 838 US property management listings · Google Maps, November 2026
This does not show that replying raises a rating. Managers who watch their profile closely are likely to ask satisfied tenants and owners for reviews and to answer complaints, so the two habits travel together. What the table does show is that the listings with the lowest median rating are also the ones that reply least.
Larger managers reply to most reviews, smaller ones to few
median reply rate for property management listings with 100 or more Google reviews
Reply habits rise steeply with review volume. Listings with 10 to 24 Google reviews reply to a median 4.5% of their recent reviews. Those with 25 to 99 reply to a median 32.5%, and those with 100 or more to a median 71.3%. The three groups hold 266, 376 and 196 listings.
The typical small profile answers almost nothing; the typical large one answers most reviews.
The chart describes who replies, not why. For a smaller manager, replying is one of the few parts of a profile where it can match a larger competitor without extra cost, since the typical small profile answers almost none of its reviews.
Managers in the South reply most, at 49%
of recent Google reviews of property managers in the South have an owner reply
By region, managers in the South reply to 49% of their recent reviews, followed by the Midwest at 44.8%, the West at 42% and the Northeast at 38.4%. Each region holds at least 126 listings, from 126 in the Northeast to 272 in the South.
Reply rates vary by about 10 points across regions.
What this means for property managers
Answer the 1-star reviews first. Only 35.5% have a reply, so a calm, factual answer already puts a manager ahead of most listings. When deciding how to respond to tenant reviews with limited time, the low ones deserve the reply more than the 5-star ones, because they are what a prospective tenant or owner reads first.
Reply within a week, and within 2 days for complaints. The median recent reply came 7 days after the review, and only 21% arrived within 2 days. Keep thank-you replies short and save the longer, specific answers for the reviews that need an explanation.
Smaller managers have the most to gain. Listings with 10 to 24 reviews reply to a median 4.5%, so answering every review is an easy way to look as attentive as a larger firm.
Vacancies are the other place a manager gets judged. If you have been searching for virtual staging near me, you do not need a local firm: photos are staged online, so an empty unit can be shown furnished before the next showing.
For older buildings in cold-weather markets, our virtual staging chicago page shows condos and two-flats furnished for winter listings.
Cite and download
Stagingmate Research. (2026). Tenant Reviews: Managers Respond to Only 35.5% of 1-Stars. Stagingmate. https://stagingmate.com/research/property-manager-review-replies
Free to use and republish, as long as you credit Stagingmate Research with a link to this page. Need a local cut or a quote? Email support@stagingmate.com.
Frequently asked questions
Less than half the time. 44.5% of 25,545 recent Google reviews of property managers have an owner reply, and the median listing replies to 27.5%.
35.5% of the time, against 49% for 5-star reviews. Across all one- and two-star reviews the rate is 35.6%.
Managers who answer a 1-star review write a median 384 characters, a few sentences, against 147 for a 5-star review.
For reviews posted in the 8 weeks before collection, the median reply came 7 days later. 21% of replies came within 2 days and 53.2% within a week.
They do in this sample. Listings that reply to every review have a median 4.6 stars, against 3.5 for listings that never reply. The data shows a pattern, not a cause.



