stagingmate
Data study · Housing market

Property Management Reviews: Repairs in 53% of Complaints

In property management reviews on Google, 22.7% of 25,545 recent reviews are 1 star and 68.2% are 5 stars. Among tenants' one- and two-star reviews, 53% mention maintenance and repairs, the most common complaint, followed by fees and charges at 36.5%. Security deposits come up in 28.6% of tenant complaints but only 4.1% of tenants' positive reviews.

Analysis of 25,545 Google reviews of 838 US property management listings · the newest 40 reviews of listings with 10 or more reviews, up to 20 per state, collected November 2026

Stagingmate Research
Published Nov 11, 2026 · 8 min read
Brass mailboxes and a ring of keys in an apartment lobby
Data source
Google Maps business listings for property management companies, and the newest Google reviews of each listing with their star ratings and text
Collected
November 2026
Sample
838 US property management listings with at least 10 Google reviews, up to 20 per state, and their newest 25,545 reviews (up to 40 per listing); tenant themes from 3,489 written reviews that read as tenants', owner themes from 1,358 that read as owners'

Key findings

  1. 122.7% of 25,545 recent property management reviews on Google are 1 star, and 68.2% are 5 stars.
  2. 2Maintenance and repairs is the most common tenant complaint: it appears in 53% of tenants' one- and two-star reviews.
  3. 3Fees and charges come up in 36.5% of tenant complaints, and security deposits in 28.6%, against 4.1% of tenants' positive reviews.
  4. 443.3% of reviews that read as tenants' give fewer than 3 stars, against 37.4% of reviews from property owners.
  5. 5Staff manner is the leading theme in tenants' positive reviews, at 46.3%.
  6. 6Owners' low reviews mention communication in 43.7% of cases, against 29.8% of tenants' low reviews.
  7. 7The median property management listing in the sample has a 4.0-star rating.

Summary

A renter has been waiting on a repair through a hot spell. He opens the management company's Google profile to leave a review and scrolls past a run of 1-star ratings from other tenants, mixed in with 5-star thank-yous to a leasing agent. Later that day a landlord looking for someone to manage her rental reads the same page and tries to work out which reviews describe the service she would get.

Property management reviews are read by two audiences at once: renters deciding where to apply, and owners deciding who should run their homes. Ratings for property managers are split between 5 stars and 1 star, so the average says little and the text says more. This study reads 25,545 recent Google reviews of 838 property management companies across the US, separates the reviews that read as a tenant's or an owner's, and measures which themes appear when each group is unhappy.

Repairs dominate. Maintenance and repairs appears in 53% of tenants' one- and two-star reviews, ahead of fees and charges at 36.5% and move-in and move-out at 30%. Money disputes are the sharpest signal: security deposits come up in 28.6% of tenant complaints but in only 4.1% of tenants' positive reviews. On the positive side, tenants most often mention staff manner, in 46.3% of their 4- and 5-star reviews.

What we measured

In November 2026 we took Google Maps business listings for property management companies in all 50 states and kept those with at least 10 Google reviews. From each state we drew up to 20 listings in a fixed shuffled order, which spreads the sample across each state's list rather than taking its most prominent names, and collected the newest 40 Google reviews of each, or every review if it had fewer. 838 listings returned reviews, giving 25,545 reviews with their star ratings and text.

Of those, 19,107 have at least 20 characters of text. We identified the writer from the words of the review. A tenant review mentions renting, such as tenant, renter, resident, a lease, an apartment, moving in or out, a maintenance request, a work order or a security deposit, and does not read as an owner's review. An owner review refers to the writer's own rental or property under management, or describes the writer as an owner, investor or landlord. 18.3% of written reviews read as tenants' and 7.1% as owners'; the rest do not say who wrote them and are left out of the theme figures.

We sorted tenant and owner reviews into nine themes with fixed keyword rules: maintenance and repairs, communication and responsiveness, security deposit, fees and charges, move-in and move-out, staff manner, leasing and application, rent and payments, and the owner side of the business, such as finding tenants, vacancies and monthly statements. A review can match several themes or none. A complaint is a review with 1 or 2 stars and a positive review has 4 or 5. For tenants that gives 1,512 complaints and 1,912 positive reviews; for owners, 508 complaints and 831 positive reviews.

Limits: the tenant rule shares some words with the themes, such as maintenance request and security deposit, so those themes are partly built into who counts as a tenant and their shares run high. Keyword rules capture topics, not verdicts: the staff manner rule matches praise for a helpful leasing agent as well as a complaint about a rude one. 8% of tenant complaints and 10.2% of owner complaints match none of the themes. The newest 40 reviews cover each listing's recent history, not its full record. No review is quoted or paraphrased, and no figures are split by state, since each state has at most 20 listings.

Property manager ratings split between 5 stars and 1 star

22.7%

of recent Google reviews of property managers are 1 star

Of the 25,545 reviews, 68.2% give 5 stars and 22.7% give 1 star. The middle is thin: 4.4% are 4 stars, 2.5% are 3 stars and 2.2% are 2 stars. The median listing in the sample has a 4.0-star rating.

Google reviews of property management companies, by star rating
5 stars
68.2%
4 stars
4.4%
3 stars
2.5%
2 stars
2.2%
1 star
22.7%
Source: Stagingmate analysis of 25,545 Google reviews of 838 US property management listings · Google Maps, November 2026

Two peaks: most reviews are 5 stars, and more than one in five is 1 star.

People review a property manager when something has gone very well or very badly, and the result is a profile with two peaks. With more than one review in five at 1 star, most property management reviews pages show complaints near the top, and a reader sees both kinds of experience side by side.

Tenants rate their manager lower than owners do

43.3%

of tenant reviews give fewer than 3 stars, against 37.4% of owner reviews

18.3% of the 19,107 written reviews read as tenants' and 7.1% as owners'. Tenants are the harsher group: 43.3% of their reviews give 1 or 2 stars, against 37.4% of owner reviews. Their average rating is 3.23 stars, against 3.48 for owners.

Tenant and owner reviews of property managers
WriterShare of written reviewsUnder 3 starsAverage stars
Tenant18.3%43.3%3.23
Owner7.1%37.4%3.48

Writers identified from the words of the review; reviews that do not say who wrote them are left out. Source: Stagingmate analysis of 25,545 Google reviews of 838 US property management listings · Google Maps, November 2026

Both groups are far more critical than the sample as a whole, in which 24.9% of reviews are under 3 stars. Reviews that name a lease, a deposit or a rental property are often written to explain a problem, while many short 5-star reviews never say who the writer is.

Maintenance and repairs lead tenant complaints at 53%

53%

of tenants' one- and two-star reviews mention maintenance or repairs

In the 1,512 tenant reviews with 1 or 2 stars, maintenance and repairs appears in 53%. Fees and charges follow at 36.5%, then move-in and move-out at 30%, communication at 29.8%, staff manner at 28.8% and security deposits at 28.6%. Leasing and applications come up in 13.3%, and rent and payments in 8.8%.

Share of tenants' one- and two-star reviews mentioning each theme
Maintenance and repairs
53%
Fees and charges
36.5%
Move-in and move-out
30%
Communication and responsiveness
29.8%
Staff manner
28.8%
Security deposit
28.6%
Owner side: finding tenants and returns
14%
Leasing and application
13.3%
Rent and payments
8.8%
Source: Stagingmate analysis of 1,512 one- and two-star Google reviews from tenants of US property management listings · Google Maps, November 2026

Repairs come up in more than half of tenant complaints.

Repairs run through a whole tenancy, from the first work order to the final walk-through, so it fits that they lead. The figure is also lifted by the way tenants were identified, since a mention of a maintenance request is one of the signals of a tenant review. Even so, maintenance appears in tenant complaints well ahead of any money theme.

Deposits and fees surface mostly when tenants are unhappy

28.6%

of tenant complaints mention the security deposit, against 4.1% of positive tenant reviews

Comparing complaints with positive reviews shows which themes mark a bad experience. The security deposit is in 28.6% of tenant complaints and 4.1% of positive tenant reviews, about seven times the rate. Fees and charges are in 36.5% against 11.6%, and rent and payments in 8.8% against 3.5%. Maintenance is mentioned in both, 53% of complaints and 36% of positive reviews, since happy tenants describe repairs too.

Themes in tenants' complaints and positive reviews of property managers
ThemeTenant complaints (1,512)Positive tenant reviews (1,912)
Maintenance and repairs53%36%
Fees and charges36.5%11.6%
Move-in and move-out30%20.1%
Communication and responsiveness29.8%26.7%
Staff manner28.8%46.3%
Security deposit28.6%4.1%
Owner side: finding tenants and returns14%4.2%
Leasing and application13.3%7.9%
Rent and payments8.8%3.5%

Complaints have 1 or 2 stars; positive reviews have 4 or 5. A review can match several themes or none. Source: Stagingmate analysis of 3,489 written Google reviews from tenants of 838 US property management listings · Google Maps, November 2026

Money themes are the clearest dividing line. A tenant rarely mentions the deposit when a tenancy ends well, and when the deposit does come up it is far more often in a low review. Move-out is the point where the deposit, fees and the final inspection meet, which helps explain why move-in and move-out appears in 30% of complaints.

Staff manner leads the praise in tenant reviews

46.3%

of tenants' 4- and 5-star reviews mention staff manner

In the 1,912 positive tenant reviews, staff manner is the top theme at 46.3%, ahead of maintenance and repairs at 36% and communication at 26.7%. Move-in and move-out appears in 20.1% of positive reviews, fees in 11.6% and leasing and applications in 7.9%.

Share of tenants' 4- and 5-star reviews mentioning each theme
Staff manner
46.3%
Maintenance and repairs
36%
Communication and responsiveness
26.7%
Move-in and move-out
20.1%
Fees and charges
11.6%
Leasing and application
7.9%
Owner side: finding tenants and returns
4.2%
Security deposit
4.1%
Rent and payments
3.5%
Source: Stagingmate analysis of 1,912 four- and five-star Google reviews from tenants of US property management listings · Google Maps, November 2026

Positive tenant reviews talk about people; complaints talk about problems.

Staff manner is the one theme that appears more often in positive tenant reviews (46.3%) than in complaints (28.8%). In positive reviews, how staff behave is the most common subject; in complaints, the repair, the fee or the deposit usually is.

Owners flag communication more often than tenants do

43.7%

of owners' one- and two-star reviews mention communication

Owners write fewer reviews, 1,358 in the sample, and their complaints have a different emphasis. Maintenance and repairs still leads, in 52.4% of owners' one- and two-star reviews, but communication is close behind at 43.7%, against 29.8% of tenant complaints. Staff manner appears in 37.4% of owner complaints and fees in 36.2%. Owner-side topics such as finding tenants, vacancies and statements come up in 20.5%.

Themes in owners' and tenants' complaints about property managers
ThemeOwner complaints (508)Tenant complaints (1,512)
Maintenance and repairs52.4%53%
Communication and responsiveness43.7%29.8%
Staff manner37.4%28.8%
Fees and charges36.2%36.5%
Move-in and move-out22.6%30%
Owner side: finding tenants and returns20.5%14%
Security deposit18.1%28.6%
Rent and payments13.8%8.8%
Leasing and application13.2%13.3%

Complaints have 1 or 2 stars. A review can match several themes or none. Source: Stagingmate analysis of 25,545 Google reviews of 838 US property management listings · Google Maps, November 2026

For an owner, the manager is the go-between with the tenant and the source of reports on the property, so a slow reply weighs heavily. Fees matter to both groups almost equally, at 36.2% of owner complaints and 36.5% of tenant complaints, while the deposit is mainly a tenant concern.

What this means for property managers

Fix the repair process first. Maintenance and repairs appears in 53% of tenants' complaints and 52.4% of owners', so it is the one theme both sides of the business agree on. Clear timelines for work orders, and an update when a repair runs long, address the most common subject in property management reviews.

Make deposit and fee rules plain before move-in. Security deposits appear in 28.6% of tenant complaints and only 4.1% of positive reviews, and fees in 36.5% against 11.6%. A written move-out checklist and itemized charges take much of the surprise out of the moment that most often turns into a low review.

Owners want to hear from their manager. Communication appears in 43.7% of owner complaints, so a regular report on repairs, vacancies and rent is cheap insurance against a bad review from the client who pays the fee.

Vacant units are also where the marketing starts. Empty rooms photograph small, and a renter scrolling listings has to picture the furniture. Managers searching for virtual staging near me do not need a local firm: photos are staged online, so a vacant unit can be shown furnished between tenants.

For units with a compact second bedroom, virtual bedroom staging shows renters that a bed and nightstands fit before they book a viewing.

Cite and download

Cite this study

Stagingmate Research. (2026). Property Management Reviews: Repairs in 53% of Complaints. Stagingmate. https://stagingmate.com/research/what-tenants-complain-about-in-property-manager-reviews

Use this data

Free to use and republish, as long as you credit Stagingmate Research with a link to this page. Need a local cut or a quote? Email support@stagingmate.com.

↓ Download the data (CSV)

Frequently asked questions

Maintenance and repairs. It appears in 53% of tenants' one- and two-star Google reviews, ahead of fees and charges at 36.5% and move-in and move-out at 30%.

Related studies